When the Oscar race starts to get me down as it does every year when it’s finalized and put to bed — for most it’s just another day, another contest, another Super Bowl. For me, it’s recorded history that I then sift through the following year to try to make sense of it. I always think of it like heading into the Grizzly Maze in hopes that I can remain objective but as the season wears on and the bears start eating their cubs it’s impossible not to feel like Timothy Treadwell, trying to “fix” nature and losing one’s mind while doing so. Good times.

But the one part of the Oscar race that gives me joy and makes me feel hopeful both for the future of the Academy Awards, as such, and the future of film overall is the short categories. The films I’ve seen there are so good, so worth your time and best of all they aren’t driven by marketing teams or advocates — they are just the movies, chosen because they were well made and their stories well told.

I have to once again whine about the lack of female subjects in both the animated shorts and the live action shorts. Only one of the live action shorts is (sort of) about a woman but really it’s about a man. I wonder if this dynamic will ever change? Probably not, when your voting body is made up mostly of men. But it didn’t used to be this way. Many decades of Oscar featured stories about women — good ones and bad ones. All About Eve, Gone with the Wind, Terms of Endearment and even Titanic. I just wonder what happened. Why did they just go completely away?

Nonetheless, the shorts illustrate vital storytelling nonetheless. I won’t go through all of them — but you should see all of them. Both the doc shorts and the live action shorts will take you to far reaches of the world to different countries with different points of view about our human experience.

The best of all of them, I think, is the documentary short Inocente. Maybe it’s because the film’s subject, artist Inocente, is so utterly compelling or maybe it’s the broader points it makes about immigrant life in Southern California among the invisible who can’t be US citizens, but are stuck here. The “dreamers” as Obama calls them. Maybe it means more to you if you live here in California, or maybe not. Inocente is, above all other things, a film about why we make art. We make art because we have to. They tell you this when you are first starting out if you study in the arts but if you don’t feel that compulsion to do it you’ll never know what they mean by that. Inocente is a kid who can’t stop it. It bursts forth from her as naturally as the air she breathes. It isn’t a question of being “good” at it. That comes later. She is good at it, of course. It is that she does it, day in and day out. But the film isn’t just about a natural artist — it’s about a person who appears to have been kissed by sunshine. Homeless, living from shelter to shelter with her mother and brother, so badly abused by her father that she had to go on the run with her mother, and enduring a complex relationship with her mother now. She can’t leave, she can’t stay.

We first meet Inocente as she’s painting her face. She is drawn to bright colors and they seem to follow her everywhere. The same way that the sunlight illuminates the brightness in flowers so does Inocente bring the color everywhere she goes. It seems sickly sweet as I’m telling it but I dare you not to be won over by her. Here in LA we live parallel lives with invisible people. They are the gardeners, housecleaners, nannies, dishwashers in white communities. They are referred to simply as “illegals.” In their communities they are building lives we never see. Inocente is the story of one girl, one artist, who broke free of all known stereotypes by simply not accepting them. As Bob Dylan would say, she’s got everything she needs, she’s an artist, she don’t look back. I will be surprised if Inocente doesn’t win but you know, you never know.


There is at least one American storyteller in the live action shorts this year, and that’s Sean Christensen. With many awards already under its belt, Curfew stands out for several reasons but the one that struck me at first was that it is written and directed by its star, Christensen. That means we have a new auteur on the scene — a gifted writer, director and actor like that doesn’t come around very often. Curfew is a surprisingly moving story about a guy who’s on the brink of suicide. The phone rings and it’s his sister – can he come watch her daughter. It is surprising at every turn, this movie, as you think the kid is going to turn out to be your run of the mill brat. But of course, she’s not. You think he’s going to turn out to be a flake but you see a different person than the one you think he will be.


I think Curfew will win and you’ll get no complaints from me. The film I was most impressed by was Buzkashi Boys, which won’t win because it contains a couple of scenes of animal brutality. I’m sorry filmmakers of the world but the Academy voters can’t stomach anything but the most soothing of stories, especially these days as most of them are in retirement or headed that way. Notice what kinds of films keep winning Best Picture? Yeah, write it down and remember it. Losing the Oscar for narrative short should send no message at all to Sam French, whose films lifts the veil on street life for young boys in Afghanistan. In such a short time, French gives us such richness of character. One kid is a blacksmith’s son. He must follow his family’s tradition of pounding out metal. The other kid has no home, no family but wants to ride in the goat dragging sport Buzkashi. It’s filmed in Kabul by Afghan and international filmmakers and is deeply moving in how the sad, hopeless story plays out. A brief discussion on Facebook I saw first said many didn’t like this year’s selection of live action shorts, and further, that this film was “too brutal” for them watch. So voters probably won’t connect with this film — and that is yet another reason why the Oscar race should be taken for what it is and not expected to be something it isn’t. Alas.


Finally, in the animated category, I was transported by both Adam and Dog and Paperman in vastly different ways. They remind me of Lincoln and Argo. Adam and Dog is Lincoln — languid, poetic, meandering but profound by the end. Paperman is lean, flawless, balanced and a general audience crowdpleaser.  Both are good.  Adam and Dog features stunning animation of a dog wandering an undetermined path. It is a symbolic dog, of course — Dog’s place in our lives perhaps.   Neither dog nor man were meant to wander alone and yet here they do until they find each other.  It’s lovely watching this dog move through the various landscapes, his movements and body language dead-on accurate.  Maybe you have to be a dog lover to really have it sink into your soul, like being someone who loves Abe Lincoln is going to enjoy Lincoln more but I have always been admiring and grateful for dogs who seem to offer us nothing but friendship and love.  It might not win because it is too particular a taste for all people to agree upon it.  Paperman, however, is a movie anyone can get and anyone can love.  It is the story you expect but not in the way you expect it.  For that reason, Paperman is probably going to win.

All of the shorts this year are every bit as good as the features up for the big prize and they are well worth your time to see them.  You’ve no doubt seen the animated shorts by now, so which one did you like best?

  • The Pesky Shorts

    Okay, so some have written in asking how to see the pesky shorts before putting in predict…
  • Live Action Shorts Links

    The Wabbit sent in this link to the live actioners: The Door (17m – Ireland/Russia) …
  • Oscar Nominated Shorts

    Thanks to N8. As he says, watch them quick before they’re removed! Kris Tapley also …
Load More Related Articles
Load More By Sasha Stone
Load More In News
  • CJ

    I really enjoyed Inocente — but not not nearly as much as Mondays at Racine.

  • Jorge

    I liked Henry and Death of a Shadow more than Curfew. For some reason that one just didnt appeal to me. Of the animated Adam and Dog is better but agree Paperman will likely win.

  • DBibby

    I thought the animated shorts were a relatively weak bunch compared to other years but I did love Adam and Dog and I hope it wins. I suspect Paperman will win however, which was perfectly likeable and a decent second choice.

    As for the live action shorts, I’ve only seen two, but of these I loved Curfew. Brilliantly acted and truly moving. I can’t wait to see the rest.

  • Cory

    I loved Adam and Dog, too. I assume you know it’s a re-telling of the Creation story from Genesis, from before the creation of Eve through to the expulsion from the garden? Besides the lush animation, I loved how “man’s best friend” was portrayed as right by his side from the very beginning, no matter what choices he made.

    Something interesting happened at the screening in Philadelphia on opening weekend: an older couple walked out of the theater not five minutes into Adam and Dog, which was the first up of all the nominees. No doubt they were offended by the portrayal of Adam’s nakedness. Since Eve hadn’t made an appearance yet, I wonder if they were unaware of the reason Adam was naked, that it wasn’t some kind of gratuitousness but merely a depiction of the Biblical description of his nakedness. Regardless, the couple that walked out was older, like many Academy members, presumably, so I wonder if that will hurt the film’s chances.

  • Reno

    Maggie Simpson will win!

  • Seeing docs tomorrow.

    Loved Adam and Dog…so beautiful.

    I really liked Shadow of Death…but will be very happy if Curfew wins. I noticed in the credits that he also wrote a song! Auteur indeed!!

  • alan of montreal
  • I thought it was the best overall grouping of live action and animated shorts in a while. There wasn’t a bad one in the bunch.

    My favorite two animated were “Head Over Heels” and “Paperman,” which together seemed like bookends of a relationship.

    I was fascinated by “Death of a Shadow,” liked the quirky, dark humor of “Curfew,” but I agree with you on “Buzkashi Boys.” I thought it was fantastic.

  • Comment

  • Sorry, this jumped to “Submit” somehow. But I totally agree with you about “Buzkashi Boys”! I was fortunate enough to have seen it in Montreal and got to know Sam French, it’s terrifically talented young filmmaker. And yes, he is all that.

    Living in Kabul, Afghanistan for four years “Buzkashi Boys” is like a movie from a planet we’ve never seen depicted before. It’s elegiac. And the cinematography! Wow!

    You can see my interview with Sam French and his producer Ariel Nasr if you click on my name above.

    I’m so happy I was able to capture this in Montreal! Did he tell me, off-camera, that they had submitted this beautiful amazing short film to Toronto and that they had turned it down?

    Oh, right, they don’t do American shorts at TIFF.

    But I’ll bet you dollars to donuts, they won’t turn down Sam French’s NEXT film!

    Which is why Montreal’s Festival des Filme du Monde is still relevant. I’ve been going there for 14 years.

    Sam French, remember that name! He’s gonna be big!
    And I’ll bet his next film will be set and about Afghanistan, too. And IN Afghan!

  • Bob W

    But Sasha what did you think of the “Eve” in Adam & Dog? You’re concerned about women’s presence in films these days, but that cartoon seemed to suggest an idea of women “messing things up” for man.

  • Ian

    For animated, Fresh Guacamole all the way. It’s less than 2 minutes long, but it’s a minute and 40 seconds of sheer brilliance and ingenuity and that counts for a whole lot. Not really a story there, but sometimes visuals need to speak for themselves, and they certainly do in this tiny yet effective stop motion masterpiece.

    For live action, I also was a huge Curfew fan, but I thought the originality of the concept behind Death of a Shadow was brilliant. Telling a sci/fi mythological tale as a short film can be extremely challenging, but yet this film pulled it off and resonated strongly on an emotional level by the end. It really made me want to see the concept evolved into a full length feature film. But Curfew had a brilliant script and great performances by all 3 of the primary cast, and will probably win and deserves to win. For script and acting, the award goes to Curfew. For originality and philosophical and emotional resonance, the award goes to Death of a Shadow.

  • Adam and Dog, Mondays at Racine, and Curfew were my favorites in their respective categories.

    I think the races are down to Adam and Dog/Paperman, Mondays at Racine/Open Heart/Inocente (really hard to call), and Curfew/Henry

  • Pierre de Plume

    First, I’m glad, Sasha, that you’re giving space to the short films. Some of our most creative filmmaking is done here.

    So far I’ve only seen the animated shorts. I feel the category as a whole is a bit weaker this year. My favorite was the 2-minute “Fresh Guacamole.” Two of the Honorable Mention entries – more experimental in nature – I felt were worthy of being nominated: “Abiogenesis,” from New Zealand, and the jazzy Jackson Pollock-inspired entry, “Dripped,” which can be viewed on Vimeo.

  • Jack

    Most of the pundits are rooting for Open Heart and I have to agree. After seeing the shorts, it was by far the one with the most important message emotional and incredibly shot. Innocente was also ok and nicely photographed, but it felt like an MTV show. The music made me crazy by the end. The cancer film, Racine felt manipulative, but it was ok.
    Very strong docs but Open Heart will win.

  • Free


    DOC SHORT: “Open Heart”

    SHORT – Animated: “Paperman”

    SHORT – Live: “Buzkashi Boys”

    Have you read Ebert’s review of the shorts? He also thinks Buzkashi is the best of the live short bunch, but he seemed a little annoyed with Curfew, like it was trying to be funny but wasn’t.

    @Ian: Finally! Thank you! I thought Paperman was great, but why aren’t more people talking about Fresh Guacamole? I thought it was beautifully done.

  • Warrior Rabbit

    I saw the animated and live action shorts yesterday. Like a previous commenter, I also think the animated ones were weaker than last year’s…but all anjoyable.

    Fresh Guacamole was very clever, but it’ll be between Paperman and Adam and Dog. I liked both. The scene where the dog was walking through the field and disturbing the fireflies… so evocative. I am a big dog lover, and it was very obvious that the animators loved dogs as well. And I found it to be an thoughtful, innovative twist to the Creation story.

    I think Curfew and Asad were my favorites in the live action category. Death of a Shadow was smart and very steampunk, but something was off about it for me. I can’t put my finger on it. Buzkashi Boys was stark and sad, and I’m not sure that fighting over a decapitated goat will be any less appealing to the Academy voters than it was to me, and I am not old and decrepit. Honestly, I couldn’t help but think that blacksmithing was head and shoulders above Buzkashi riding, so the dream never really resonated. What did strike me was the message of hopelessness, of accepting your status, of not having dreams (they’re deadly).

    What a contrast to Asad, another tale of boys growing up in challenging, limited, unsophisticated, morally compromising, dangerous environments with few choices and no room for dreams. But what a vastly different feel and approach — like night and day, perhaps best embodied by the moods and outlooks of their male role models.

Check Also

Predictions Friday – Manchester and Moonlight Get a Boost

It isn’t that people weren’t predicting Kenneth Lonergan’s Manchester by…