I know he’s famous for his writing in addition to his acting. I guess I never figured he was this good of a writer:
Blackfish could’ve easily been yet another monotonous “save the whales” documentary where they give us all the facts about the human-created plights of whales both in and out of captivity. Instead of preaching and using pretty but uninspired long-lens shots of whales frolicking peacefully in the ocean, the documentary, like so many successful action and crime movies, relies on visceral violence in the context of the age-old battle of man versus Mother Nature. This is amplified by the film’s main setting, an amusement park ostensibly designed for parents hoping to instill joyful memories in their young children. Is the severe trauma of a relative handful of impressionable kids worth the happiness of those who were spared what on the surface are lovely ballets of beast and human but under the waves and splashes are constructs of abuse and violence? When you fuck with animals, it’s inevitable that every once in a while the wild underbelly rises to the surface and someone is killed, and sometimes it’s in front of the children! In the age where there are so many choices for entertainment, it’s overwhelming (and one where, as far as I can tell, young children are more entertained by iPads than anything else), do we really need to be training animals for human amusement anymore? I am not here to answer that question, but it’s not going to do you any harm to ponder it and decide where you stand.
The Academy may or may not nominate Blackfish on January 16. That would be using their power wisely. They are not known for such things. The Act of Killing is still the frontrunner but Blackfish just need a nomination. Fingers crossed.
I’d much rather trust the trainers and biologists at Sea World and other zoos to take care of endangered species than James Franco and the film school dropouts that made this doc.
Critic Michael Sicinski has a dissenting (and to my mind, much more accurate) view on the film:
http://www.nashvillescene.com/nashville/the-hit-documentary-blackfish-has-a-message-as-dubious-as-its-methods/Content?oid=3507212
I fully support the movie as an activist and politically-conscientious individual. The blindness towards our cruelty towards animals on a mass scale is far more disturbing than any of us think about in our daily lives. I wonder if, in 100 years, we will look back and think, “Did we just all think that was ok?”
^But by that I primarily mean the systematic viciousness with which we treat millions and millions of cows, chickens, etc. The issue of whales is not the biggest animal rights issue at all (SeaWorld ought to be finished, yes, but the documentary, as important as it is, barely scratches the surface, focusing on a relative handful of animals in comparison to the thousands we slaughter daily without thinking). Nonetheless people need to wake up, and this documentary will help.
At the end of the day, though, this is not a brilliant example of documentary work. It’s important, yes (though _An Inconvenient Truth_ remains more important, and we could use another one of those). There is only one documentary this year that truly pushes the boundaries of HOW we think of cruelty… and that is _The Act of Killing_.
Killer whales should not be used for entertainment and they should not be bred in captivity anymore, but “Blackfish” is hardly an accurate film.
http://micechat.com/53915-blackfish-exposed/
Most moving and thought provoking documentary I saw last year. Finger’s crossed.