This site collects top ten lists and compiles them year by year. This is how it’s shaking down for 2014. I’ve bolded the Best Picture contenders via the pundit consensus thus far. Unbroken does not show up on the top 50 here but it does have two votes over at Movie City News.
1. Boyhood (324 lists; 118 top spots)
2. The Grand Budapest Hotel (232 lists; 17 top spots)
3. Birdman (181 lists; 24 top spots)
4. Under the Skin (175 lists; 34 top spots)
5. Whiplash (166 lists; 18 top spots)
6. Nightcrawler (136 lists; 5 top spots)
7. Gone Girl (135 lists; 6 top spots)
8. Selma (120 lists; 14 top spots)
9. Ida (119 lists; 12 top spots)
10. Inherent Vice (113 lists; 15 top spots)
11. Only Lovers Left Alive (99 lists; 6 top spots)
12. Force Majeure (92 lists; 1 top spot)
13. Snowpiercer (84 lists; 5 top spots)
14. The LEGO Movie (83 lists; 4 top spots)
15. Guardians of the Galaxy (80 lists; 3 top spots)
16. Two Days, One Night (79 lists; 7 top spots)
17. The Immigrant (75 lists; 4 top spots)
18. The Babadook (65 lists; 3 top spots)
19. Foxcatcher (64 lists; 3 top spots)
20. Goodbye to Language (63 lists; 15 top spots)
21. Interstellar (63 lists; 8 top spots)
22. Citizenfour (63 lists; 6 top spots)
23. Mr. Turner (58 lists; 5 top spots)
24. The Imitation Game (53 lists; 3 top spots)
25. Listen Up Phillip (50 lists; 3 top spots)
26. Edge of Tomorrow (49 lists)
27. We Are the Best! (48 lists; 2 top spots)
28. Life Itself (45 lists; 1 top spot)
29. A Most Violent Year (44 lists; 4 top spots)
30. The Theory of Everything (41 lists; 3 top spots)
31. Love is Strange (41 lists; 2 top spots)
33. Calvary (38 lists; 4 top spots)
34. Stranger by the Lake (35 lists; 4 top spots)
35. Blue Ruin (34 lists; 2 top spot)
36. Wild (34 lists; 1 top spot)
36. Manakamana (34 lists; 1 top spot)
38. The Raid 2 (32 lists; 2 top spots)
39. Mommy (29 lists; 3 top spots)
40. Stray Dogs (29 lists; 1 top spot)
41. Leviathan (28 lists; 4 top spots)
42. Obvious Child (28 lists; 1 top spot)
43. Winter Sleep (27 lists; 1 top spot)
44. Nymphomaniac (26 lists; 1 top spot)
45. Norte, the End of History (24 lists; 1 top spot)
46. Dear White People (22 lists; 1 top spot)
47. Dawn of the Planet of the Apes (20 lists)
48. American Sniper (19 lists; 1 top spot)
49. Top Five (19 lists)
50. National Gallery (18 lists; 2 top spots)