Quantcast

Brillante Mendoza’s Kinatay

Posted by Ryan Adams On May - 25 - 2009

Trying to provide a video sampler today of the major award-winners at Cannes, but it hasn’t been easy finding a representative clip from Kinatay which earned Best Director honors for Brillante Mendoza. I wondered how this video could possibly have much appeal as a promo, until I read that much of the movie is just like what we see here. Shaky night shots of a road trip en route to a gruesomely violent destination. (”Kinintay” means “slaughtered” or “butchered.”)

When it comes to accurately predicting awards these past few years, Roger Ebert has a track record pitted with potholes, but his brutal dismissal of Kinatay is rough enough to warrant a quote:

Here is a film that forces me to apologize to Vincent Gallo for calling “The Brown Bunny” the worst film in the history of the Cannes Film Festival… You mark my words. There will be critics who fancy themselves theoreticians, who will defend this unbearable experience, and lecture those plebians like me who missed the whole Idea. I will remain serene while my ignorance is excoriated. I am a human being with relatively reasonable tastes. And in that role, not in the role of film critic, I declare that there may not be ten people in the world who will buy a ticket to this movie and feel the money was well spent.

Some might respond that not every movie can be as good as Knowing, but Ebert is not alone in his revulsion. I’d be happy to excerpt something from a favorable review for Kinatay — if I could find one. The New York Times says it’s “a grisly, widely loathed shocker.” The Star reports on the crowd’s reaction at the awards ceremony:

Many of the winners last night at the Palais des Festivals came right out of left field, and were greeted with boos and catcalls by film critics watching the ceremony via closed-circuit TV in the adjoining Debussy Theatre…

This reaction was nothing, though, compared to the gasps of outrage that greeted the awarding of the Best Director prize to Filipino helmer Brillante Mendoza for Kinatay, a horrific drama about a man who rapes, murders and dismembers a young prostitute.

Sometimes we feel envious that Cannes transpires and concludes with so many movies none of has seen and therefore cannot rationally judge or root for. But maybe we should be thankful that we don’t have much emotional investment in whatever more beautiful films we might have been hoping would win instead of the often bizarre selections made by the jury.

  • Filed under: AWARDS CHATTER
  • |
  • Tags: ,

  • | |

    32 Responses for "Brillante Mendoza’s Kinatay"

    1. Guy Lodge May 25th, 2009 at 5:18 am 1

      Sukhdev Sandhu at the Telegraph was impressed.

      Hope that helps.

    2. Ryan Adams May 25th, 2009 at 5:19 am 2

      Thanks, Guy.

      Though the praise exists as a single sentence…
      “This is a fiercely moral and horribly unforgettable denunciation of societal corruption.”

      …after first warning:
      “Frankly, most people will find Kinatay (it means ‘butchered’) either unremittingly tedious, harrowing or vile.”

    3. Jan Sijera May 25th, 2009 at 6:19 am 3

      Beauty is in the eye of the beholder..quoting from the “Little Prince”..everyone is entitled to their own opinion..I just hope that hollywood critics and film makers will be open to realism after all a film is a reflection of the reality in our society..and not just the reflection of special effects..c”,)

    4. Jeremie May 25th, 2009 at 9:11 am 4

      I don’t know why everybody keeps saying that he was booed when the award was announced. It absolutely not the case. Check it for yourself, the whole ceremony is online on Cannes website. It is the same for Best Screenplay. Someone said it was greeted by loud booing… Well we obviously did not watch the same ceremony.

      http://festival-cannes.canalplus.fr/video/ceremonie-de-cloture

      If you don’t want to watch the whole ceremony you can just select the awards you want to watch on the right menu next to the video (screenplay and director are at the bottom)

    5. cjKennedy May 25th, 2009 at 9:11 am 5

      Mendoza’s idea of realism seems to be cheap shock value. I haven’t seen Kinatay, but Serbis was wretched.

    6. cjKennedy May 25th, 2009 at 9:12 am 6

      If I understand the accounts correctly Jeremie, the critics were watching the ceremony by feed at a different location. They were the ones that booed, not the audience who were actually present.

      But who cares what a bunch of worn out festival critics think, right?

    7. hihi May 25th, 2009 at 10:02 am 7

      Congratulations Brillante Mendoza

      I guess in time we will understand your artistry.

    8. Barrett May 25th, 2009 at 11:36 am 8

      Radical director. Radical movie.

      Shakes the establishment up and what is perceived to be right and proper according to critics.

      Perhaps this movie will be a Best Foreign Film nominee at next year’s Oscars.

      Wonder what Ebert will say then.

    9. Ryan Adams May 25th, 2009 at 11:49 am 9

      “Wonder what Ebert will say then.”

      He’d either ask, “Who abducted all the AMPAS members older than 55 and replaced them with cool French people?” or maybe, “My condolences to the families of the 2000 elderly members of the Academy who disappeared in The Rapture. God have mercy on those of us who are Left Behind.”

    10. hehe May 25th, 2009 at 12:27 pm 10

      http://www.screendaily.com/reviews/cannes-reviews/kinatay/5001258.article

      “Showing the kidnap, beating, humiliation, rape, murder and dismemberment of a young prostitute, Brillante Mendoza’s new film Kinatay (which means “butchered” in Tagalog) is a nerve-shredding exploration of crime which is both repellent and grimly compelling. Offering audiences no relief or redemption, it is perhaps most notable for its daring in attempting to capture the moment a young man crosses the line into irrevocable evil.”

    11. Diane May 25th, 2009 at 2:05 pm 11

      Cannes really likes its depressing movies. I applaud realism in films, but from what I’ve read, Kinatay is a film comprised mostly of long, endless shots of a car driving through highways, ending with a graphic murder and vivisection of a prostitute. I don’t see anything inspiring, or challenging about it, other than to shock people and to confront people with the evil of this world. Are we getting so numb, that we need this type of film to shock our senses and minds?

    12. blizzards14Proud2bPINOI May 25th, 2009 at 6:32 pm 12

      Just rewatched Breaking the waves and was moved when Bess’ sister in law shouted, “You have no right to consign her to hell!”

      We have no right to dismiss this film when after all we haven’t seen it yet. Since when most people here have become critics ass lickers.

      We have to think for ourselves.

      What shocked me the most was that Mendoza had won the same award Wong Kar Wai, Truffaunt, The Coens, Ang Lee and tarantino had previously won.

      He was in our school last February (at the University of Sto. Tomas) lecturing about his film Serbis and Tirador.

      Who would have known back then that he will win the Best Director from the coolest films fest (and the most exclusive and reliable one) 3 months after?

    13. blizzards14Proud2bPINOI May 25th, 2009 at 6:37 pm 13

      I never thought that I will live the day a filipino movie will be a top in an exclusive thread here at Awards Daily.

      Fuck off haters. For once I will enjoy this moment like a watermelon and dont you dare throwing any Afrika here or I will slice you with Filmboymichael.

    14. Dewey May 25th, 2009 at 7:48 pm 14

      blizzard,

      you like the violence from the tone of your last post.

    15. bridgie james rosenthal May 25th, 2009 at 9:58 pm 15

      At last! A Filipino film becomes the much-talked about winner at Cannes this year (not to mention the foregone “Antichrist”)… Good buzz or bad buzz is still buzz, and it will not generate that kind of talk if the film went home empty-handed… Proud to be Pinoy!

    16. dela May 25th, 2009 at 11:06 pm 16

      lol, blizzards. I am happy for you. :)

    17. Michael Bo May 26th, 2009 at 5:03 am 17

      I really felt that I inhabited the skin of this young policeman of ‘Kitakay’, and experienced everything through his eyes, in reel time which makes the goings-on more shocking that just watching the dismemberment (of a corpse, mind you, she was killed before they dismembered her, makes a huge difference!). Every time this boy had an option to either stay and do nothing, stay and take action or simply scram, I felt it as a pressing personal option for me as well. I admire this film so much.

      And yes, last year I loved ‘Serbis’. Although maybe I think Mendoza’s ‘Slingshot’ (Tirador) is his masterpiece thus far.

    18. blizzards14Proud2bPinoi May 26th, 2009 at 3:19 pm 18

      Hehehe.

      Thanks dela.

      I think the french love filipino films. They even have a library dedicated for Brocka’s film.

      This is a magnificent time for Filipino films.

    19. blizzards14Proud2bPinoi May 26th, 2009 at 3:20 pm 19

      Im not claiming that Mendoza is a GREAT director but Im just elated.

      Is he the next Wong Kar Wai?

    20. Aleksis May 26th, 2009 at 6:27 pm 20

      “Is he the next Wong Kar Wai?”

      No.

    21. bridgie james rosenthal May 26th, 2009 at 8:03 pm 21

      “Im not claiming that Mendoza is a GREAT director but Im just elated.

      Is he the next Wong Kar Wai?”

      Wow! Mendoza will be surprised and delighted for sure. Dante is known for being humble (we talked over the phone a day after he won the award and he cannot imagine it happening…) They have their own narrative and structural techniques, but Wong Kar-wai is more popular overseas. The former has a long way to go, even if his films are getting “relative” mileage at Cannes.

      Dante’s in Manila already and I can’t wait to talk to him again about the prospects of releasing an “uncut” (or French) version of “Kinatay” here.

    22. Diane May 26th, 2009 at 9:49 pm 22

      I don’t understand the comparison between Mendoza and Wong Kar Wai. If you are only comparing them because they are both non-Caucasian, than that is a VERY superficial comparison.

      Also, if you’ve seen any Wong Kar Wai film, you wouldn’t even mention the two names together as their films are nothing alike. Seriously, what the hell? I’m not making a value judgement against Mendoza’s films, but I don’t get why the comparison was brought up in the first place.

    23. Carlo May 26th, 2009 at 11:13 pm 23

      filipino pride!:D

    24. Ron Cruz May 27th, 2009 at 1:25 am 24

      Very soon, the discussion will go to whether or not “Kinatay” merits being sent as the Philippines’s official entry to the Best Foreign Language Film category. On one hand, it has achieved what no other Filipino film has, bagging such a prestigious award and generating so much dialogue (positive and negative both). On the other, it’s probably too violent for the Academy members who generally prefer less shocking fare. Then again, maybe we have to send something jolting and controversial to finally be noticed. At the very least, the voters are going to know about the film before it even screens for them.

    25. blizzards14 May 27th, 2009 at 3:08 am 25

      @diane

      Dont get me wrong. Im not comparing the two based on the merits of their work.

      Oh yes, Im being superficial because I based it on the fact that they are both non-caucasian (Asian actually). (btw, why is it from a caucasian’s view point?) I was just asking if he would be the next Asian “it” director. That’s all.

      Anyways, Im sooo happy that he won. He could use this to penetrate Hollywood and make a more accessible film.

    26. David May 27th, 2009 at 11:17 am 26

      This Brillante Mendoza is a fraud! Making calculated movies publicized to be “realistic” when they are not and are only made to sensationalize dastard/repulsive things!

    27. winsjon27 May 27th, 2009 at 11:48 am 27

      I have been here on this site for about 3 1/2 years now and this is the first time a whole lot of Filipinos commented. I am Filipino and I hate this movie Kinatay (as well as Serbis). Reality isn’t one sided in our country and I am sad that the only Filipino reality that’s been recognised abroad is a film about rape and butchery. There is nothing new about this film both artistic and technical wise. I am all for Filipino directors being recognise abroad but with a film such as this, I am a little bit ashamed. Congratulations Brilliante Mendoza, but it’s about time you do a good Filipino film after this crap.

    28. Ponderer May 27th, 2009 at 6:19 pm 28

      To David about his “calculated realism”:

      I live in a Filipino neighborhood where butchered or not butchered cadavers are being dump. These poor souls are even luckier than those “desaparisidos.” And come to think of it, in our country…we don’t have serial killers. So…who do the killings?

    29. Diane May 27th, 2009 at 10:19 pm 29

      Is the film an honest and realistic depiction of the kind of crime and violence that happens there? I was just wondering, because if so, then I guess, you can say that Mendoza is just bringing to light the vile and cruel things that humans do to other humans there.

      I also think you shouldn’t applaud a film just because it’s directed by someone of the same nationality as you. If you truly like the film, than fine, but for all those who liked it, can you explain to me why?

    30. Gilbert Luis R. Centina III June 2nd, 2009 at 8:34 am 30

      I would like to congratulate Brillante “Dante” Mendoza for his best director award. He more than deserves it. His depiction of evil in the movie Kinatay is a tremendous success. We must really present evil in any form as totally repulsive. Literature is an artistic interpretation of life. Mendoza´s way is meta-realistic and for that he deserves the highest cinematic accolade.

    31. Gilbert Luis R. Centina III June 2nd, 2009 at 8:47 am 31

      By accurately depicting evil as totally repulsive, Brillante “Dante” Mendoza, this year´s Cannes´best director, has ushered in the Age of Dante in filmmaking. Art films will never be the same again.

    32. Ed Cruz August 23rd, 2009 at 2:35 am 32

      A Film is a medium of expression of the Director, the society, the scriptwriter and all those involved in the making of it. As audience, our task is to live and experience the creative message of ‘Kinatay’. We should not expect every cinematic experience to be profound, preachy, lyrical,philosophical as we want it to be. If you were disgusted, disturbed, puzzled and irritated with ‘Kinatay’, then the film succeeded in relaying its message. It is a social commentary that is real and true. If you are living in a 1st world country or states, then you will not appreciate the movie. Go out and see the world from another perspective. This is it. Leaving your seat and half-watching the film speaks about your myopic viewpoint of what you wanted to see and experience.


    Leave a reply


    • Contender Tracker

      Best Picture
      Up in the Air
      Nine
      The Hurt Locker
      An Education
      Precious: Based on the Novel
      Push by Sapphire

      A Serious Man
      Inglourious Basterds
      Up

      Julie & Julia
      Star Trek
      District 9
      Bright Star
      Where the Wild Things Are
      A Single Man

      Best Actor
      Jeff Bridges, Crazy Heart
      Colin Firth, A Single Man
      George Clooney, Up in the Air
      Matt Damon, The Informant!
      Jeremy Renner, The Hurt Locker
      Viggo Mortensen, The Road
      Ben Foster, The Messenger
      Michael Stuhlbarg, A Serious Man
      Michael Sheen, The Damned United

      Best Actress
      Gabby Sidibe, Precious
      Carey Mulligan, An Education
      Meryl Streep, Julie & Julia
      Abbie Cornish, Bright Star
      Helen Mirren, The Last Station
      Michelle Monaghan, Trucker

      Best Supporting Actor
      Christoph Waltz, Inglourious Basterds
      Alfred Molina, An Education
      Stanley Tucci, Julie & Julia
      Peter Sarsgaard, An Education
      Robert Duvall, Crazy Heart
      Peter Capaldi, In the Loop
      Zach Galifianakis, The Hangover
      Anthony Mackie, The Hurt Locker
      Brian Geraghty, The Hurt Locker

      Best Supporting Actress
      Mo'Nique,Precious
      Anna Kendrick,Up in the Air
      Maggie Gyllenhaal, Crazy Heart
      Julianne Moore, A Single Man
      Melanie Laurent, Inglourious Basterds
      Vera Farmiga, Up in the Air
      Samantha Morton, The Messenger
      Emma Thompson, An Education
      Cara Seymour, An Education

      Best Director
      Jason Reitman, Up in the Air
      Lee Daniels, Precious
      Kathryn Bigelow, The Hurt Locker
      Lone Scherfig, An Education
      Quentin Tarantino, Inglourious Basterds
      Joel and Ethan Coen, A Serious Man
      Neill Blomkamp, District 9
      Spike Jonze, Where the Wild Things Are
      Tom Ford, A Single Man
      Jane Campion, Bright Star

      Best Original Screenplay
      Mark Boal, The Hurt Locker
      Joel and Ethan Coen, A Serious Man
      Jane Campion, Bright Star
      Quentin Tarantino,Inglourious Basterds
      Michael Haneke,White Ribbon
      Bob Peterson, Pete Docter,Up
      Scott Neustadter, Michael H. Weber, 500 Days of Summer

      Best Adapted Screenplay
      Jason Reitman, Sheldon Turner, Up in the Air
      Nick Hornby, An Education
      Spike Jonze, Dave Eggars, Where the Wild Things Are
      Peter Morgan, The Damned United
      Geoffrey Fletcher, Precious: Based on the Novel Push by Sapphire
      Scott Burns, The Informant!
      Tom Ford, A Single Man

      Best Editing

      Chris Innis, Bob Murawski, The Hurt Locker
      Sally Menke, Inglourious Basterds
      Dana E. Glauberman,, Up in the Air
      Joel and Ethan Coen,, A Serious Man

      Best Cinematography
      Greig Fraser,Bright Star
      Robert Richardson,Inglourious Basterds
      Roger Deakins, A Serious Man
      Christian Berger, White Ribbon
      Bruno Delbonnel,Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
      Barry Ackroyd, The Hurt Locker

      Best Art Direction

      Where the Wild Things Are
      Julie & Julia
      Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
      Bright Star
      Inglourious Basterds
      White Ribbon
      District 9
      A Serious Man

      Best Sound Mixing

      Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
      District 9
      Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
      The Hurt Locker
      Star Trek

      Best Sound Editing

      District 9
      Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
      Star Trek
      Up

      Best Costume Design
      Janet Patterson, Bright Star
      Jany Temime,Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince
      Anna B. Sheppard,Inglourious Basterds
      Mary Zophre, A Serious Man
      Colleen Atwood, Public Enemies
      Consolata Boyle,Cheri

      Best Original Score
      Carter Burwell, Karen O,Where the Wild Things Are
      Carter Burwell,A Serious Man
      Michael Giacchino,Up
      Alexandre Desplat, Cheri
      Elliot Goldenthal, Public Enemies

      Best Foreign Language Film (submissions)

      Letters from Father Jacob, Finland
      White Wedding, South Africa
      A Prophet, France
      Dawson, Isla 10, Chile
      Nobody to Watch Over Me, Japan
      Prince of Tears, Hong Kong
      No puedo vivir sin ti, Taiwan
      Kelin, Kazakhstan
      Mother, Korea
      The White Ribbon, Germany
      Silent Army, The Netherlands


      Best Documentary Feature

      The Beaches of Agnes
      Burma VJ
      The Cove
      Every Little Step
      Facing Ali
      Food, Inc.
      Garbage Dreams
      Living in Emergency
      The Most Dangerous Man in America
      Mugabe and the White African
      Sergio
      Soundtrack for a Revolution
      Under Our Skin
      Valentino
      Which Way Home


      Best Animated Feature
      Up
      The Princess and the Frog
      Coraline
      The Fantastic Mr. Fox
      A Christmas Carol
      Mary and Max
      Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs
      Ponyo


      Best Visual Effects
      Star Trek
      District 9
      A Christmas Carol
      Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
      Transformers


      Best Makeup

      Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
      District 9

      Best Song

      Best Live Action Short

      Best Animated Short

      Best Documentary Short

      China’s Unnatural Disaster: The Tears of Sichuan Province
      The Last Campaign of Governor Booth Gardner
      The Last Truck: Closing of a GM Plant
      Lt. Watada
      Music by Prudence
      Rabbit a la Berlin
      Tell Them Anything You Want: A Portrait of Maurice Sendak
      Woman Rebel

    • Ampas Breakdown

      Actors-1,222
      Producers-462
      Executives-436
      Sound-411
      Writers-388
      Art Directors-373
      Directors-375
      Public Relations-370
      Members at Large-254
      Shorts/Feature Ani-335
      Visual Effects-272
      Music-233
      Editors-227
      Cinematographers-197
      Documentary-145
      Makeup-115
      Total Voting Members -approx 6,000
    • Tuesday, December 1, 2009: Official Screen Credits forms due

      Monday, December 28, 2009: Nominations ballots mailed

      Saturday, January 23, 2010: Nominations polls close 5 p.m. PT

      Tuesday, February 2, 2010: Nominations announced 5:30 a.m. PT, Samuel Goldwyn Theater

      Wednesday, February 10, 2010: Final ballots mailed

      Monday, February 15, 2010: Nominees Luncheon

      Saturday, February 20, 2010: Scientific and Technical Achievement Awards presentation

      Tuesday, March 2, 2010: Final polls close 5 p.m. PT

      Sunday, March 7, 2010: 82nd Annual Academy Awards presentation