| Anne Thompson (Indiewire) |
Hugo |
Tree of Life |
Hugo |
A Separation |
Hugo |
Hugo |
Undefeated |
Saving Face |
Rango |
Flying Books |
Tuba |
Rise |
The Artist |
The Artist |
Muppet |
Iron Lady |
Anne Thompson (Indiewire) |
| Richard Rushfield Daily Beast |
Hugo |
Tree of Life |
Jane Eyre |
A Separation |
Hugo |
Hugo |
Undefeated |
God/Elvis |
Rango |
Morning Stroll |
Pentecost |
Rise |
The Artist |
The Artist |
Muppet |
Iron Lady |
Richard Rushfield Daily Beast |
| Susan Wloszczyna (USA Today) |
Hugo |
The Artist |
Anonymous |
A Separation |
Hugo |
Hugo |
Paradise Lost 3 |
Cherry Blossom |
Rango |
Flying Books |
The Shore |
Rise |
Hugo |
The Artist |
Muppet |
Iron Lady |
Susan Wloszczyna (USA Today) |
| Michael Musto, Village Voice |
Hugo |
Tree of Life |
The Artist |
A Separation |
Hugo |
Hugo |
Paradise Lost 3 |
Saving Face |
Rango |
La Luna |
Raju |
Rise |
The Artist |
The Artist |
Muppet |
Iron Lady |
Michael Musto, Village Voice |
| Pete Howell, the Toronto Star |
Hugo |
Tree of Life |
Hugo |
A Separation |
Hugo |
Hugo |
Paradise Lost |
Cherry Blossom |
Rango |
Flying Books |
The Shore |
Rise |
Hugo |
The Artist |
Muppet |
Iron Lady |
Pete Howell, the Toronto Star |
| Sean O'Connell (Hollywood News |
Hugo |
Tree of Life |
The Artist |
A Separation |
Hugo |
Hugo |
Paradise Lost 3 |
Baghdad |
Rango |
La Luna |
Time Freak |
Rise |
Hugo |
The Artist |
Muppet |
Iron Lady |
Sean O'Connell (Hollywood News |