Film Comment says Bling Ring “Casts such a Lovely Spell”


The first review of note for Sofia Coppola’s The Bling Ring is by Kent Jones for Film Comment, calls it among her best, alongside Lost in Translation and Somewhere:

Like Somewhere, The Bling Ring sneaks up on you. Somewhere during the first visit to Paris Hilton’s house (if it isn’t the real thing, it could just as well be), you might find yourself, as I did, alternately charmed, mesmerized, and horrified by the lives of the characters and the homes they enter. Halfway through the film, Marc and Rebecca wander through what is supposedly Orlando Bloom’s open-plan house at night, viewed from an exquisite remove several tiers above in the Hollywood hills, the sounds of howling coyotes and wailing police sirens quietly echoing in the distance—a suspended spell of uncanny beauty, and one of the most beautifully lyrical stretches I’ve seen in a movie in ages.

I’m not sure if Coppola’s film ends as satisfactorily as it might have—resolving a narrative about characters who lead unmotivated lives does present its dramatic problems—but I don’t think it matters all that much. Unlike Spring Breakers, with which the film will inevitably be compared (alongside Schrader’s The Canyons), The Bling Ring goes about its business quietly but with a tremendous purity of focus. The film casts such a lovely spell that its full force may hit only after the lights come up.

Thanks to @theDeepPink for the tip.


  1. Bryce Forestieri 2 years ago

    I like THE VIRGIN SUICIDES and nothing else

    Like Dislike
  2. Colin Biggs 2 years ago

    I don’t have anything against Sofia Coppola (Lost in Translation was great), but she never seems to evolve in her filmography. She needs to expand out of her comfort zone a little.

    Like Dislike
  3. Ryan Adams 2 years ago

    Like David O. Russell. He shows us all sorts of lower-middle class misfits screaming at each other in a myriad of towns across the US.

    Like Dislike
  4. Colin Biggs 2 years ago

    I get the SLP hate (Wells didn’t make that movie endearing), but Russell made Three Kings and I Heart Huckabees. Coppola hasn’t reached out like that.

    Like Dislike
  5. K. Bowen 2 years ago

    Coppola is one of the most accomplished American filmmakers of her generation. If her name were Sofia Smith, she would be much more greatly appreciated.

    Like Dislike
  6. d 2 years ago

    Also, if her first name were Scott.

    Like Dislike
  7. The Pope 2 years ago

    Yeah, I wish Michael Mann would stop obsessing over men and their work. I mean, come on. But you know, what’s wrong with working in your wheel house? It’s like complaining that Degas only depicted ballet dancers or that Monet like lilies. So what? She does it better than anyone else. And it can’t be said often enough, capturing ephemera and providing insight into people who are inherently is no mean achievement.

    Like Dislike
  8. Jerry 2 years ago

    So it’s like every other movie she has made. That’s disappointing because the trailer made it seem like she was going out of her comfort zone for once. Oh well at least her fans will love it.

    Like Dislike
  9. Mal 2 years ago

    Inherently what? The sentence isn’t quite finished. Not trying to be a dick, just want to know what you meant.

    Like Dislike
  10. Vince Smetana 2 years ago

    Maria Antoinette was my personal favorite. Talk about casting a spell. All the others, well, I can leave them for everyone else to enjoy.

    Like Dislike
  11. d 2 years ago

    Why does she “need” to? Some of us LIKE the movies she makes.

    Like Dislike
  12. The Pope 2 years ago


    Thanks for pointing that out to me! I meant to type “people who are inherently shallow.”

    I think that is part of Coppola’s great talent. Like Antonioni, she can take the surface and move deeper than it. Like Antonioni, she deals in detachment, ennui and alienation.

    But these kids seem on another plain altogether.

    I find the criticism of Coppola to be tiresome and trite. A little bit like complaining about John Ford and westerns. Sure, he worked in other genres but that was a different era when the studio system afforded a director the opportunity to churn out a picture or two every single year. Now it’s different yet, if anyone were to bother to examine her films closely, they will see great variation between each one. The only similarity is the surface.

    Coppola is one of a kind.

    Like Dislike
  13. CMG 2 years ago

    I’d rather she write and direct stuff she has a good, firm grasp on than pretending to be some Capra-esque poser like Jason Reitman, a director who never gets questions about his family or that his skills of director are questioned with the notion he is only in his position because his father was once a good director.

    Like Dislike
  14. CMG 2 years ago

    As a DOR fan, I can say one of his most consistent touches is finding mania in the setting and characters of his movies. He’s like a cocaine-binge Fassbinder at his best. At his worst he can read like TV network production notes to make a sitcom edgier which was SLP, that I’d still re-watch but not before Three Kings, I Heart Huckabees, The Fighter or Spanking the Monkey.

    I personally think Marie Antoinette as a Lost & Translation follow-up was very different and very risky. And I cannot really say that you could make the jump from believing The Virgin Suicides to Lost & Translation is retreading ground aside from both having excellent soundtracks.

    Like Dislike
  15. CMG 2 years ago

    I love Kent Jones. If I could make his piece on The Master my new bedroom wallpaper, I’d do it. His recent piece on how ill-conceived Tarantino’s racism charge against John Ford was is also fantastic.

    Kent is not only a great mind and film critic/theorist but a great champion of certain movies. If he thinks The Bling Ring is great, my anticipation just rose a little a more.

    Like Dislike
  16. Bryce Forestieri 2 years ago

    Tarantino just feels threatened by Ford’s respect-commanding persona. The man never talked about his movies and when he did he was to put it nicely, economical, Tarantino on the other hand can speak all night about the same trash.

    Like Dislike
  17. CMG 2 years ago

    The piece is incredible:

    “Tarantino’s ill-chosen words more or less force a comparison between his recent films and Ford’s. As brilliant as much of Django Unchained and Inglourious Basterds are, they strike me as relatively straight-ahead experiences—there is nothing in either film to de-complicate; by contrast, one might spend a lifetime contemplating The Searchers or Wagon Master or Young Mr. Lincoln (39) and continually find new values, problems, and layers of feeling. And while Tarantino’s films are funny, inventive, and passionately serious about racial prejudice, there is absolutely no mystery in them—what you see really is what you get. Within the context of American cinema, Django is a bracing experience . . . until the moment that Christoph Waltz shoots Leonardo DiCaprio, turns to Jamie Foxx, and exclaims: “I’m sorry—I couldn’t resist.” The line reading is as perfect as the staging of the entire scene, but this is the very instant that the film shifts rhetorical gears and becomes yet another revenge fantasy—that makes five in a row. Is revenge really the motor of life? Or of cinema? Or are they interchangeable? Or whatever, as long as you know what side you’re on?”

    Like Dislike
  18. murtaza 2 years ago

    Somewhere was horrendous, i’ll never get my 90 mins back. one of the most terrible films i could barely sit through. Still don’t know what Coppola wanted to achieve out of it. Miserable last attempt she left on me.

    Like Dislike
  19. Jpns Viewer 2 years ago

    I quite liked Lost in Translation. *The indie aspect in terms of production, financing money, etc. though, didn’t really impress me since there are many great films, let’s say, from Japan, China and South Korea to begin with, that consumed as equal an amount of relatively lower budget than US-based big-studios’ total as Lost; but I was not dissing her nor that film.*

    Anyway, to be honest, I am looking forward to this film for Coppola’s name […] to it, what could become of her own angle about the incident, as well as the buzz around her as a director, and to an extent that about Watson, as well.

    Lost’s got it somewhere in the B scale, that is, B-, B or B+, personally from me. So, I am hoping this one will do around B- or B; given Coppola’s good name, etc., anything lower than B is a letdown to me in this case. . . . Just say’n.

    Like Dislike
  20. JeremyEM 2 years ago

    Sofia Coppola does not set out to make films that will have a broad appeal. It is not news that the vast majority of people would find ‘Somewhere’ boring.

    I for one am very glad that she gets to make films even though they are not commercial.

    Like Dislike
  21. Jpns Viewer 2 years ago

    Correction: I mean anything lower than B-, not just lower than B, (for The Bling Ring) is a letdown to me.

    Like Dislike
  22. Kane 2 years ago

    Plenty filmmakers who have famous parents will get crap if their work isn’t good enough. Sofia Coppola and Godfather Part III and (to a point) Marie Antoinette, Roman Coppola and that Charles Swan film, hell all of the Coppola clan have gotten flank now and again.

    Like Dislike
  23. Kane 2 years ago

    Somewhere? Somewhere is one of the worst films you’ve ever seen? Literally? It was SO bad you had to label it that? Geez…you’d think that movie was made by Uwe Boll with a remark like that.

    Like Dislike
  24. Gentle Benj 2 years ago

    It’s not just the positive nature of this notice that encourages me, but the tone of it. “Suspended spell of uncanny beauty,” yes! There are plenty of directors working today who are rightly praised for making tight, sharp films, but Coppola is one of the few who can create something much more diffuse while still delivering a tremendous emotional payload. First that trailer, and now this; my anticipation is going through the roof for this one.

    Like Dislike
  25. Richard Crawford 2 years ago

    …the movie is wildly entertaining…

    Like Dislike
  26. Richard Crawford 2 years ago

    K. Bowen…Yes!

    Like Dislike
  27. Sean Gallagher 2 years ago

    That link’s no longer working.

    Like Dislike
  28. Tracy 2 years ago

    Mariam I know you must be somewhere around the world but i do not know how to locate you. pleases friend where ever you are and you are able to read this message, i want you to know that its me your friend Tracy Christopher. i have finally found a solution to our life time issue of barrenness and heartbreaks. Mariam am finally married to the man of my choice and heavy with pregnancy almost getting to six months. We live happily now and i wish you can be happy like me as well. I love you Mariam and i want to introduce you to this man divinely ordained and sent to bring happiness to whom its lost. meet Dr Odogwu Malaika and reach him through his email “”

    Like Dislike
  29. jay 2 years ago

    Is your choice to make,to become rich or not, to be famous or not, is just a click to get it.
    are you a business man or woman, are
    you a musician or an artist, do you want
    to be famous or you want to become rich
    or powerful, is better you become a
    member of the Illuminate and make your
    dream come through, this is the chance
    for you now to become a member of the
    temple and get what you seek from us, if
    you are ready to become a member and
    realize your dream then email us now or
    you call us through this contact:

    Like Dislike

Sign In


Reset Your Password

Email Newsletter