• About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Clarence Moye
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • Forum
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • Forum
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
No Result
View All Result

Cream of the Crop, Top of the Heap: The Critics Who Matter Most

by Ryan Adams
August 13, 2010
in Critics
70

MetaCritic typically collects reviews from around 40 critics and Rotten Tomatoes names roughly the same number among its ‘Top Critics.’ The individual lists of critics change from film to film, with a core group of 25 who never seem to miss a movie. 20 other critics slide on and off the edges of the guest list.

Among these 4 dozen film critics there might be 10 writers so esteemed that they can help make or break a movie with their review. A few of those critics we’ll all agree about. A few more will receive less “universal acclaim.” There are only 20 critics I really give a damn about, and maybe 5 who’ve made a weekly impression on my ongoing film education over the years. We’ll all have our favorite writers; but this poll I want to assemble is not about prose skills. I’m more curious to find out who we think has clout and real industry influence.

Not particularly interested in ranking the 40 most familiar critics from best respected to least — though that ranking will soon shake out. I’d like to find out who’s at the very top. The premiere film authorities. The writers we think are the 10 or 15 most important critics in the business.

I’ve thrown together a preliminary list. We’ll take suggests and hear arguments for the next few hours. Sometime tomorrow after all the suggestions are made and gaps filled in, we’ll put the top 35-40 names in poll and open it to voting this weekend.

Find my very rough list of candidates after the cut, and let me know who I forgot to include.

* David Ansen, Newsweek
* James Berardinelli
Peter Bradshaw, Guardian UK
* Ty Burr, Boston Globe
Justin Chang, Variety
Richard Corliss, TIME
Manohla Dargis, New York Times
David Denby, New Yorker
Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
David Edelstein, New York Magazine
* Philip French, Observer
* David Germain, Associated Press
Owen Gleiberman, Entertainment Weekly
* Ed Gonzales, Slant
Pete Hammond, Boxoffice Magazine
Ann Hornaday, Washington Post
Kirk Honeycutt, Hollywood Reporter
Peter Howell, Toronto Star
* Mark Kermode, BBC & The Guardian
* Peter Knegt, IndieWire
* Anthony Lane, New Yorker
Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle
Christy Lemire, Associated Press
Lou Lumenick, New York Post
Todd McCarthy, IndieWire
Wesley Morris, Boston Globe
Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal
Andrew O’Hehir, Salon
Michael Phillips, Chicago Tribune
Claudia Puig, USA Today
Peter Rainer, Christian Science Monitor
Jonathan Rosenbaum, Chicago Reader
Rex Reed, New York Observer
Richard Roeper
Andrew Sarris, New York Observer
* Nick Schager, Slant
Lisa Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly
A.O. Scott, New York Times
Betsy Sharkey, Los Angeles Times
Dana Stevens, Slate
* David Thomson
Kenneth Turan, Los Angeles Times
Peter Travers, Rolling Stone
Stephanie Zacharek, Movieline

I’m short on UK critics and that gap needs to be adjusted a bit. I’m short on critics who write for publications between the coasts too — but that’s less important to our project. If a critic lives in a flyover state and his name’s not Ebert or Roeper, then he won’t have much influence in Hollywood. Polished prose, exquisite taste — those are great qualities, congratulations. But it’s not what we’re measuring, ok? Give me names that carry weight in the industry, and they’ll get a slot on the poll. Your other personal favorites will make fine topics for discussion in the comments, but I’ll need a good reason to put their names in this game.

Tags: criticsPOLLS
Ryan Adams

Ryan Adams

Next Post

Made In Dagenham, trailer

Sign up for Awards Daily's Breaking News

* indicates required

How Angie Wells Transformed Carey Mulligan into a Revenge-Seeking Chameleon For ‘Promising Young Woman’

Introducing the Sunset Circle Award Nominees for 2020

Photo courtesy of Focus Features

by Shadan Larki
January 22, 2021
0

Predictions Friday – Making This up as We Go Along

Predictions Friday – Making This up as We Go Along
by Sasha Stone
January 22, 2021
40

Zach Woods’ ‘David’ Gets Men to Talk About Their Feelings

Zach Woods’ ‘David’ Gets Men to Talk About Their Feelings
by Joey Moser
January 22, 2021
0

‘Palm Springs’ Cinematographer Quyen Tran on the Color That Plays a Prominent Role in This Love Story

‘Palm Springs’ Cinematographer Quyen Tran on the Color That Plays a Prominent Role in This Love Story

Courtesy of Hulu

by Megan McLachlan
January 22, 2021
0

The State of the Race: The Oscars in a Time of Division

The State of the Race: The Oscars in a Time of Division
by Sasha Stone
January 21, 2021
47

The Spirit Awards Push their Date Back from the Oscars

The Spirit Awards Push their Date Back from the Oscars
by Sasha Stone
January 21, 2021
2

Robin Wright’s Performance in Land Could Shake up the Oscar Race

Robin Wright’s Performance in Land Could Shake up the Oscar Race
by Sasha Stone
January 20, 2021
134

Cristin Milioti On What She Spent Hours On Reddit Researching about Her ‘Palm Springs’ Character

Cristin Milioti On What She Spent Hours On Reddit Researching about Her ‘Palm Springs’ Character

Courtesy of Hulu

by Megan McLachlan
January 20, 2021
0

Reframe: Minority Report

Reframe: Minority Report
by David Phillips
January 19, 2021
4

Fernando Garcia Named Executive Vice President of the Oscars

Fernando Garcia Named Executive Vice President of the Oscars
by Sasha Stone
January 19, 2021
1

Sam Feder On How ‘Disclosure’ is a Call for Action for Hollywood

Sam Feder On How ‘Disclosure’ is a Call for Action for Hollywood

(Photo: Netflix)

by Joey Moser
January 19, 2021
0

Monica Levinson On Borat Subsequent Moviefilm’s “Loveable Misogynist” Hook That Drew Her In

Monica Levinson On Borat Subsequent Moviefilm’s “Loveable Misogynist” Hook That Drew Her In

Courtesy of Amazon Films

by Megan McLachlan
January 20, 2021
4

Critics Choice Nominates 2020 Television, Not ‘WandaVision’ (Yet)

Critics Choice

(Photo: Critics Choice)

by Clarence Moye
January 18, 2021
7

Join us Facebook

AwardsDaily Crew

  • About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Clarence Moye
  • Contact Us

ADTV Crew

  • ADTV Home
  • Megan McLachlan, Co-Editor
  • Clarence Moye, Co-Editor
  • Jalal Haddad, Senior Contributor
  • Joey Moser, Senior Contributor
  • Kevin Dillon
  • Shadan Larki
  • Ben Morris
  • David Phillips

Follow on Twitter

ADTV Twitter

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Advertising on Awards Daily

© 1999-2021 AwardsDaily.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • Forum
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News

© 1999-2021 AwardsDaily.com