• About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Clarence Moye
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
No Result
View All Result

AO Scott on Catfish, A Refreshing Insight

by Sasha Stone
September 17, 2010
in News
0
AO Scott on Catfish, A Refreshing Insight

I’ve been kind of watching in muted horror as this whole Catfish thing revealed itself. After many screening invites, I really should have gone and seen it for myself. Thanks to Kris Tapley for putting me out of my misery by telling me what the film was about. The marketing strategy was starting to piss me off. The opposite to what I thought would happen HAS happened: now I really want to see the movie. AO Scott writes something new about it that I hadn’t heard before. It’s a brilliant insight, I think. Most people want to see Catfish as a cautionary tale for those of us who use social networking in place of real human interaction. But Scott looked at the film, saw opportunist filmmakers capturing a real artist — this contains SPOILERS. So we’ll quote Scott after the jump.

I mention all of these precedents to give some of the flavor of “Catfish” without spoiling it outright. But be warned: There is a big, not entirely unsurprising twist that lies like a booby trap in the middle of the film, and the choice is either to reveal what happens or forgo a discussion of the movie’s logic and meaning. The directors and the distributors would obviously prefer the second option, but the expectation of discretion is a trap. So consider yourself warned. I’ll try not to spell out too much, but neither am I willing to play along in a rigged game.

Anyway, the story goes like this: A few years ago Nev Shulman, the younger brother of one of the filmmakers, was befriended by a girl in Michigan named Abby, who seemed to be an artistic prodigy. She wanted permission to use one of Nev’s photographs as the basis of a painting, and in the course of their correspondence revealed that she was, at the age of 8, exhibiting and selling her work online and in galleries in her hometown. Nev’s fraternal friendship with Abby led to a warm rapport with her mother, Angela, and also to a blossoming cyberflirtation with Megan, the girl’s 19-year-old sister, who posted enticing profile pictures on her Facebook page.

Megan seemed to be falling in love with Nev, whom she had never met. They exchanged sexy text messages and talked on the telephone, and she posted songs that she had written and pictures of the horse farm she was about to buy. At various points in their courtship, and in his dealings with Angela, Nev experiences a qualm, and tries to persuade his brother and Mr. Joost to let him out of the movie. They bully and cajole and keep the cameras running, and Nev, seemingly the most guileless and perhaps for that reason the most decent person in “Catfish,” plays along in spite of his queasiness.

When the time comes to pay a visit to Michigan, he also shows himself to be much braver than Mr. Shulman or Mr. Joost, who turn panicky when their little investigation into the nature of reality turns strange. When the going gets weird, Hunter S. Thompson used to say, the weird turn pro, but these filmmakers never transcend their own amateurism. They turn what could have been a brilliant exploration of the hidden corners of contemporary reality into an opportunity for gawking and condescension. Look at these crazy folks out there in the sticks! Let’s go back to New York and edit the footage so our friends can see just how crazy they are!

But the object of the film’s patronizing, pitying gaze is also the person who saves it: Angela, a woman whose life is, at first glance, a web of self-delusions, compulsive deceptions and plain desperation. Her whispery, sincere, wide-eyed lies and evasions were met, at the crowded screening I attended, with derisive laughter punctuated by gasps of horror. Plain-looking and soft-spoken, she seemed to be either a clown or a monster.

She might be those things, but in spite of its own facile, faux-naïf manipulations, “Catfish” reveals her to be something else as well, namely an artist. Mr. Joost and Mr. Shulman, young and entitled filmmakers, assume that the sophistication is all on their side, but Angela’s mastery of the media of modern self-expression — from painting to social media to her very being — surpasses theirs in every way.

Some acknowledgment of this power comes in a conversation with her husband, who tells the story that gives the movie its title, but everything that is radical, disturbing and true about “Catfish” belongs to the fabulist at its center. Mr. Shulman and Mr. Joost will continue to enjoy the success and cachet of having made a pop culture conversation piece, which is a tribute to their good luck and nimble opportunism. But the dark genius of their film lies elsewhere, beyond the parameters of its slick intentions, in the wild social ether where nobody knows who anybody is.

This is one of his best reviews.

Tags: AO ScottCatfish
Sasha Stone

Sasha Stone

Sasha Stone has been around the Oscar scene since 1999. Almost everything on this website is her fault.

Next Post
TIFF Winding Down

TIFF Winding Down

Sign up for Awards Daily's Breaking News

* indicates required

Felippo Meneghetti and Barbara Sukowa Detail the Fragility of the Incredible ‘Two of Us’

Felippo Meneghetti and Barbara Sukowa Detail the Fragility of the Incredible ‘Two of Us’

(Photo: Magnolia Pictures)

by Joey Moser
January 27, 2021
0

First Gurus of Gold of the Season

First Gurus of Gold of the Season
by Sasha Stone
January 27, 2021
0

How Composer Emile Mosseri Tapped into the Delicacy of the Music of ‘Minari’

How Composer Emile Mosseri Tapped into the Delicacy of the Music of ‘Minari’

(Photo: A24)

by Joey Moser
January 27, 2021
0

Pablo Larraín Reveals First Look at Kristen Stewart in ‘Spencer’

Pablo Larraín Reveals First Look at Kristen Stewart in ‘Spencer’
by Clarence Moye
January 27, 2021
0

Delroy Lindo On His Stellar, Award-winning ‘Da 5 Bloods’ Performance

Delroy Lindo On His Stellar, Award-winning ‘Da 5 Bloods’ Performance

DA 5 BLOODS (L to R) JOHNNY NGUYEN as VINH TRAN, CLARKE PETERS as OTIS and DELROY LINDO as PAUL in DA 5 BLOODS Cr. DAVID LEE/NETFLIX © 2020

by Clarence Moye
January 27, 2021
0

WATCH: Jane Levy Discusses Returning to ‘Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist,’ the Show’s Already-Iconic Musical Numbers, and What Comes Next.

WATCH: Jane Levy Discusses Returning to ‘Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist,’ the Show’s Already-Iconic Musical Numbers, and What Comes Next.

Photo Courtesy of NBC

by Shadan Larki
January 26, 2021
0

Scripter Nominees

Berlin Dispatch – Will Win / Should Win

Orion Lee (left) as "King-Lu" and John Magaro (right) as "Cookie" in director Kelly Reichardt's FIRST COW, released by A24 Films. Credit : Allyson Riggs / A24 Films FIRST COW_11.17.18_AR_0377.ARW

by Sasha Stone
January 26, 2021
9

The State of the Race – What to Make of the Big Awards Dump of AFI, NBR and the Spirits

‘Sound of Metal’ Production Designer Jeremy Woodward on the Importance of Circles and Minimalism in the Film

SOUND OF METAL Courtesy of Amazon Studios

by Sasha Stone
January 26, 2021
31

Da 5 Bloods Tops NBR // The National Board of Review Announces 2021 Winners

Winners Announced for Inaugural “Critics Choice Super Awards”
by Sasha Stone
January 27, 2021
76

Judith Light On the Sorrow of Bobi Jewell and the Exhilaration of Dede Standish

Judith Light On the Sorrow of Bobi Jewell and the Exhilaration of Dede Standish

(Photo: Spectrum Originals)

by Joey Moser
January 26, 2021
0

2021 Film Independent Spirit Award Nominations

2021 Film Independent Spirit Award Nominations

(Photo: Focus Features)

by Clarence Moye
January 26, 2021
48

Sound of Metal Director/Writer Darius Marder Talks Ableism in Filmmaking, Turning Down Robert Duvall

darius marder

SOUND OF METAL Courtesy of Amazon Studios

by Megan McLachlan
January 26, 2021
0

The Caucus Awards for Producers, Writers & Directors to Honor Aaron Sorkin, Among Others

The Caucus Awards for Producers, Writers & Directors to Honor Aaron Sorkin, Among Others
by Sasha Stone
January 26, 2021
0

Join us Facebook

AwardsDaily Crew

  • About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Clarence Moye
  • Contact Us

ADTV Crew

  • ADTV Home
  • Megan McLachlan, Co-Editor
  • Clarence Moye, Co-Editor
  • Jalal Haddad, Senior Contributor
  • Joey Moser, Senior Contributor
  • Kevin Dillon
  • Shadan Larki
  • Ben Morris
  • David Phillips

Follow on Twitter

ADTV Twitter

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Advertising on Awards Daily

© 1999-2021 AwardsDaily.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News

© 1999-2021 AwardsDaily.com