< Streep, Close, Williams, Swinton, Theron, Mara and ... Davis - Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
  • About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Clarence Moye
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • Forum
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • Forum
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily - The Oscars, the Films and everything in between.
No Result
View All Result

Streep, Close, Williams, Swinton, Theron, Mara and … Davis

by Sasha Stone
November 22, 2011
in BEST ACTRESS, featured, Glenn Close, Meryl Streep, Michelle Williams, Rooney Mara, Tilda Swinton, Viola Davis
139

Jeff Wells has gone to bat for Meryl Streep in The Iron Lady:

You can dribble the Viola Davis basketball all over the court and shoot swish shots to your heart’s content, but that won’t change the fact that Meryl Streep’s freakishly dead-on performance as Margaret Thatcher in The Iron Lady (Weinstein, 12.30) seems like a much more likely winner of the Best Actress Oscar right now. As far as I’m concerned it’s a Streep vs. Michelle Williams (i.e., as Marilyn Monroe in My Week With Marilyn) contest with Davis half-elbowed aside.

There is no doubt that Streep turns in yet another brilliant impersonation with The Iron Lady. At some point while watching her in the film you forget completely that you’re watching Meryl Streep doing Margaret Thatcher and you feel like you are really watching Margaret Thatcher — and all of the good and bad that goes along with that. It’s sort of the same quandary Leonardo DiCaprio finds himself in in J. Edgar. We believe he’s J. Edgar. But then we have to deal with our feelings about J. Edgar.

The other problem with the Iron Lady is that the movie keeps distracting us from Streep. She is the reason to watch and yet the camera cuts away from her during her best scenes and makes us watch things we don’t really care about, like Thatcher as a youngin’. That makes it a somewhat confused biopic – it doesn’t really seem to know how it feels about Thatcher, therefore it doesn’t really take a strong point of view. On the other hand, there’s Streep to marvel at — and one cannot deny the power of her intelligence as an actress and her ability to completely alter herself to play another person. It’s truly astonishing. She and Glenn Close are the two vets this year who disappear in their roles and unearth characters who are brilliantly played but not exactly the kind you warm to. And that, in the end, might prove difficult where the Oscars are concerned.

To my mind, it’s tough to choose between Glenn Close and Meryl Streep this year in terms of who gave the more impressive transformative performance. You can’t really say Streep is better than Close this time. It’s perhaps the first time that situation has ever occurred. They are both working at the very top of their game — accents and makeup, posture and vocal inflections — they are both lost and stuck with an inability to express themselves. And yet both seem a bit hindered, too, by these constraints – with Streep, the makeup seems to pen her in too much – she is at her best when she’s got her own skin on and is playing Thatcher as we remember her. Close is at her best when she can strip herself of her Albert Nobbs costume and the real woman emerges.

They both play characters who aren’t warm and fuzzy. My own hatred for Margaret Thatcher made me not want to watch the movie, frankly. I tend to watch Meryl Streep movies over and over again. But I had to realize that I only watch the ones where I like the character. It was great to see Phyllidia Lloyd not try to smooth out the rough edges of Thatcher but even still, it’s hard to forget. Hard to remember. Hard to watch.

And then there is Michelle Williams as Marilyn – Williams is also a good mimmic — and seems to capture what Marilyn Monroe had in some ways, and yet form her own character in other ways (I still haven’t seen it but I’m going by what I’ve read).

Tilda Swinton is probably the next in line here, and will get competition from Rooney Mara for the dark character in the group. Mara utterly transforms herself for Dragon Tattoo in a way that is going to be, I suspect, too big to ignore. Charlize Theron is the third in this group for consideration. One of these three will probably get in.

There is no urgency to award Meryl Streep a second Oscar – she holds the record for the most nominations and had won two already. She will come out again with yet another brilliant performance next year and the year after that. You have to ask yourself, why this year? Michelle Williams also seems to have many more opportunities laid out for her. And finally, Glenn Close is the only one who should be in the conversation for winning, to my mind. She has never won. She should have over the years.

But the one actress who still shines brightly this year is the one whose film will be a strong Best Picture contender, one of 2011’s most profitable films, led by an all-female cast, and starring a girl who grew up so poor they couldn’t afford heating or even a telephone. An unlikely frontrunner, Viola Davis still stands out. It isn’t just that she great in The Help – it’s that it’s the flipside of The Blind Side. In that film, another very profitable one, the “Whitey” that Saves All ended up with the Oscar. In The Help, Emma Stone isn’t the one who’s headed for the Kodak; Viola Davis is. I can’t tell you the amount of goodwill that will fill the house if Davis is called up there to accept this, the second Oscar given to a black actress in 84 years of Oscar history. She just has to get close enough for that to be a possibility. And if it’s a possibility, it can be a reality.

Of course, nothing the Academy does surprises me anymore — it’s possible Viola Davis won’t even be nominated. Obviously if that happens it gets back down to Streep vs. Close.

Tags: Charlize TheronGlenn CloseMeryl StreepMichelle WilliamsTilda SwintonViola Davis
Sasha Stone

Sasha Stone

Sasha Stone has been around the Oscar scene since 1999. Almost everything on this website is her fault.

Next Post

A Dangerous Method opens in New York to strong support

Sign up for Awards Daily's Breaking News

* indicates required

Reframe: Minority Report

Reframe: Minority Report
by David Phillips
January 19, 2021
0

Fernando Garcia Named Executive Vice President of the Oscars

Fernando Garcia Named Executive Vice President of the Oscars
by Sasha Stone
January 19, 2021
0

Sam Feder On How ‘Disclosure’ is a Call for Action for Hollywood

Sam Feder On How ‘Disclosure’ is a Call for Action for Hollywood

(Photo: Netflix)

by Joey Moser
January 19, 2021
0

Monica Levinson On Borat Subsequent Moviefilm’s “Loveable Misogynist” Hook That Drew Her In

Monica Levinson On Borat Subsequent Moviefilm’s “Loveable Misogynist” Hook That Drew Her In

Courtesy of Amazon Films

by Megan McLachlan
January 19, 2021
4

Critics Choice Nominates 2020 Television, Not ‘WandaVision’ (Yet)

Critics Choice

(Photo: Critics Choice)

by Clarence Moye
January 18, 2021
4

The Case for News of the World

The Case for News of the World
by Sasha Stone
January 18, 2021
9

Consider Uggie, Episode 2: Was Uggie an LGBTQ Icon?

Consider Uggie, Episode 2: Was Uggie an LGBTQ Icon?

Courtesy of MUBI/Ariztical Entertainment

by Megan McLachlan
January 18, 2021
0

Hunter Doohan On Adam’s Guilt and Questionable Choices for Showtime’s ‘Your Honor’

Hunter Doohan On Adam’s Guilt and Questionable Choices for Showtime’s ‘Your Honor’

(Photo: Skip Bolen/SHOWTIME)

by Joey Moser
January 18, 2021
0

‘Palm Springs’ Editor Matt Friedman On the Risks They Took with That Montage Scene

‘Palm Springs’ Screenwriter Andy Siara Talks the Film’s Dinosaurs and How Hall & Oates Became the Closing Song

Courtesy of Hulu

by Megan McLachlan
January 18, 2021
1

‘Crown,’ ‘Ozark,’ Netflix Dominate Critics Choice TV Awards

“The Stuff Of Which Fairy Tales Are Made…”

The Crown S4. Picture shows: Diana Princess of Wales (EMMA CORRIN). Filming Location: Military Hostel Front, Malaga

by Clarence Moye
January 18, 2021
6

‘Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist’ EP Austin Winsberg Dishes Out Some Major Clues About Season Two

‘Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist’ EP Austin Winsberg Dishes Out Some Major Clues About Season Two

Photo: Sergei Bachlakovr/NBC

by Shadan Larki
January 18, 2021
1

Crip Camp Tops the 2020 IDA Documentary Awards

Crip Camp Tops the 2020 IDA Documentary Awards
by Sasha Stone
January 16, 2021
2

Desperately Seeking Best Movie Compilations

Desperately Seeking Best Movie Compilations
by Sasha Stone
January 16, 2021
18

Join us Facebook

AwardsDaily Crew

  • About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Clarence Moye
  • Contact Us

ADTV Crew

  • ADTV Home
  • Megan McLachlan, Co-Editor
  • Clarence Moye, Co-Editor
  • Jalal Haddad, Senior Contributor
  • Joey Moser, Senior Contributor
  • Kevin Dillon
  • Shadan Larki
  • Ben Morris
  • David Phillips

Follow on Twitter

ADTV Twitter

  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Advertising on Awards Daily

© 1999-2021 AwardsDaily.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Oscar Predictions
    • Best Picture
    • Best Actor
    • Best Actress
  • Good As Gold
  • Forum
  • AD TV
  • Podcasts
  • FYC Gallery
  • Interviews
  • All News

© 1999-2021 AwardsDaily.com