• About Us
  • Advertising on Awards Daily
Friday, March 24, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily
  • Home
  • Good As Gold
  • AD TV
  • Calendar 2023
  • Podcasts
  • Interviews
  • Follow us on Twitter
    • Awards Daily
    • Sasha Stone
    • Ryan Adams
    • Clarence Moye
    • Mark Johnson
  • All News
  • Home
  • Good As Gold
  • AD TV
  • Calendar 2023
  • Podcasts
  • Interviews
  • Follow us on Twitter
    • Awards Daily
    • Sasha Stone
    • Ryan Adams
    • Clarence Moye
    • Mark Johnson
  • All News
No Result
View All Result
Awardsdaily
No Result
View All Result


What is a Critic? The Curious Case of No Reviews for “What is a Woman”

by Sasha Stone
June 8, 2022
in featured, News
78
What is a Critic? The Curious Case of No Reviews for “What is a Woman”

Download: What is a Critic? The Curious Case of No Reviews for "What is a Woman"

When the Daily Wire launched a new documentary called “What is a Woman” they invited critics to evaluate the film. Not a single film critic took them up on their offer. Only one review is featured at a Rotten Tomatoes and that is by the Daily Wire and Hollywood in Toto’s Christian Toto.

The reception to the invitation was so extreme that Matt Walsh published the responses on his Instagram:

Why would they be so afraid? Because the subject is Matt Walsh, who is considered at the very top of the enemies list on Twitter, alongside Ben Shapiro, Elon Musk and Donald Trump (when he was on Twitter). Walsh says that he is now the recipient of death threats. Even associating with him at all could probably get someone fired if they reviewed the film.

What is a Woman is a more or less a profile of Matt Walsh. The film more or less reflects his past year of asking the question to activists, “what is a woman” since apparently this is a difficult thing to explain. No one wants to be called a TERF.  It’s a bit of a word tangle because of the conflicting declarations from the Left that “trans women are women” but then the word salad of having to contort to be inclusive by saying things like “birthing people” or vagina havers.” It comes from a well-intentioned place. They don’t want anyone to feel marginalized or left out but in so doing it does beg the question, well then how do you define “woman”?

He’s written a children’s book called Johnny the Walrus (deemed anti-trans), he has a podcast, he went on Dr. Phil.

 

Granted, it’s understandable that they would not want to give oxygen to someone they consider transphobic. And more importantly, put their own jobs on the line. Don’t forget that Sean O’Connell nearly lost his job at Cinemablend for writing a review some deemed “offensive.” Any film critic reviewing this documentary, which is far more controversial than the movie Red would ever be, could get fired.

I am not shaming them for opting out. I completely understand that, as should everyone.

Some journalists have covered it, like Jeff Wells at Hollywood-Elsewhere:

The main impetus behind the hardcore progressive wokester cabal is not just about showing compassion and acceptance for historically marginalized or put-upon communities (African Americans, women, LGBTQ, transgender), but also about bending over backwards to make things right by abruptly and radically reversing biological embeds. One way of achieving this is by threatening sensible centrists and left-moderates with toxic social-media accusations and even career destruction.

Either you’re with us or you’re a racist or a sexist or a homophobe or an anti-trans bigot. Either you’re with us or you’re crabgrass, and you need to be yanked out of the soil. I can’t wait until these fine folks are on the run and searching for tall grass.

And Matt Taibbi, who is fearless when it comes to covering things journalists are too afraid to touch – you should read his whole piece — writes:

Which brings us to Matt Walsh’s new movie, What is a Woman?, simultaneously the most talked-about and most ignored documentary in the world. The movie, which tries and fails to get trans activists, academics, and medical professionals to offer a definition of womanhood, is both trending and more or less totally un-reviewed. The most prominent outlets who’ve admitted to watching it have names like the Christian Postand Spectator Australia, despite a 96% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The film is narrated by Walsh and distributed by Ben Shapiro’s conservative Daily Wire, which is crucial to understanding why it will be a success even if — especially if — no mainstream reviewers touch it.

The controversy in the film could have been explored to great effect by someone on the “other side,” but since the topic mostly just terrifies people over here, the entire debate has become the property of conservatives like Walsh and Christopher Rufo by default. (There’s a small community on the left of people like Dansky that’s been trying to elevate various concerns for years, without much success — more on them in a moment).

That is the problem here, that no one on the other side, no prominent film critic, has either the freedom or the courage to cover this. It seems strange to me that everyone is so afraid, even if I know their jobs will be on the line. So why isn’t everyone standing up against that? Why aren’t they standing by their writers?

The only reason I’m covering it, because believe me, the last thing I need is for the activists on Twitter who are the most militant and vicious to come after me or those who work for me. I debated it for a while. If I ignored it I would not bring any trauma on myself or my crew. If I ignored, though, I would also be missing an important story with regard to the evolution of film criticism, and I think that matters a lot.

As of this moment, there is such a strident and terrifying climate of fear that activists have tried to get Netflix to dump Dave Chappelle and Ricky Gervais – and to Netflix’s credit they refused. They have gotten a number of very good journalists fired from their jobs – like Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal of the Blocked and Reported podcast, not to mention Andrew Sullivan from New York Magazine. They have tried to get books banned and have forced publishing companies to punish or censor content they deem offensive. While this is true across the board with almost every group on the Left (see the latest hilarious suspension of Dave Weigel from The Washington Post for RTing a dumb joke, David Edelstein dumped from NPR for a joke on Facebook, and on and on it goes) it is most extreme with the transgender activists online.

Extremism begets extremism, however, and they are losing more supporters and allies than they are attracting because of their demands for ideological compliance with a fast-moving movement that starting to scare parents away from voting for the Democrats (to be blunt). No one is allowed to ask questions. Jobs are threatened. They have silenced journalists, scientists, educators – and now, apparently, film critics.

A while back I mentioned that the pendulum was starting to swing and the backlash was coming. In silencing all dissent and conversation on the Left, that has handed over the debate about this issue to the Right where they have absolutely no problem talking about it. Trump will be shouting it from the rooftops. That means people are going to start taking sides for or against. If there is no reasonable voice in the middle helping the majority through this, they are going to flip to the Right and they are going to want to watch Matt Walsh’s documentary, especially since everyone is silent about it everywhere else.

The Conservative site The Daily Wire has been branching out and trying to compete, even if in a small way, with Hollywood’s lurch towards progressive political content. They have released three feature films already, two of them with a central female protagonist saving the day, and a third that will launch this week that was produced by, and stars, Gina Carano called Terror on the Prairie. That will mean three of their feature films will be action movies with a central female star.

Walsh, I think, knows that just asking the question makes his point. It can’t be answered in the way he believes it should be, that it’s a biological, not ideological, definition. He shows both sides in terms of how they would answer that question. On the Left, it’s very much: gender is a social construct and gender is fluid because it is about identity. On the Right or in the middle it’s very much about biology – that for all of human existence men and women are defined by their reproductive organs.

I don’t think most people in this country agree with him about transgender people or their rights, but neither do they agree with the other end of the spectrum. Most people are somewhere in the middle. They deserve to have some critics cover this film, even if they trash it.

Things are evolving very quickly on the Left, with new rules being implemented every day and those rules are mandated upon anyone who wants to be accepted into the community of good people doing good things. If anyone on the Left objects to any of it – from President Biden on down – they are staying silent. But journalists and, I’d argue, film critics are required to rise above that fear.

This Bill Maher video, which addresses what I am talking about here, already has 3 million views:

We have a very LGBTQ community here at AwardsDaily and we always have. After all, I once helped someone avoid suicide in the darkest days when Crash beat Brokeback. That might seem silly to some, but it was a trauma to those whose love for the Oscars collided with what they viewed as homophobia in rejecting Brokeback Mountain. We have an intersectional staff here as well.  That, more than anything, is why I didn’t want to cover this topic. I don’t want to hurt my readers here or my staff.

But I also don’t want to be yet another person too afraid to talk about something. If you remember nothing else remember this: information, like truth, like art wants to be free.

What is a Woman is available on the Daily Wire for $12. Or probably, by now, on Youtube.

 

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • WhatsApp
  • Print
Tags: Best DocumentaryDaily Wire
Sasha Stone

Sasha Stone

Sasha Stone has been around the Oscar scene since 1999. Almost everything on this website is her fault.

Related Posts

2023 Emmy Predictions: Have Our Drama and Comedy Series Emmy Winners Marched In?

2023 Emmy Predictions: Have Our Drama and Comedy Series Emmy Winners Marched In?

by Clarence Moye
March 24, 2023
2

It's time to start taking the Emmy race seriously. Especially since the month of March debuted two extraordinarily strong contenders...

The Best of SXSW 2023: ‘Air,’ ‘John Wick,’’Dungeons & Dragons’ and More Epic Crowd-Pleasers

The Best of SXSW 2023: ‘Air,’ ‘John Wick,’’Dungeons & Dragons’ and More Epic Crowd-Pleasers

by Shadan Larki
March 24, 2023
6

I’m a few days removed from SXSW 2023; I’ve given myself time to sit with the 30+ movies and TV...

Apple Joins Amazon in Committing to Help Save Theaters

Apple Joins Amazon in Committing to Help Save Theaters

by Sasha Stone
March 23, 2023
55

The debate rages on as to whether films in theaters will survive. We already know event films will have no...

Poll: Choose Your Most Anticipated Movies of 2023

Poll: Choose Your Most Anticipated Movies of 2023

by Ryan Adams
March 22, 2023
47

Welcome to Phase 2 of this year's massive poll with the goal to narrow down and focus in on our...

Doezzz ‘Yellowjackets’ Zzzeason 2 Avoid the Dreaded Zzzophomore Zzzlump?

Doezzz ‘Yellowjackets’ Zzzeason 2 Avoid the Dreaded Zzzophomore Zzzlump?

by Clarence Moye
March 21, 2023
0

We're back after a week off following the Academy Awards, and we're diving into one of our most feverishly anticipated...

SXSW Film & TV Festival Announces 2023 Audience Award Winners

SXSW Film & TV Festival Announces 2023 Audience Award Winners

by Shadan Larki
March 20, 2023
7

Eva Longoria’s feature directorial debut "Flamin’ Hot” took the top prize. Special prizes and juried award winners were announced earlier...

Next Post
Rebecca Wisocky On Hetty Finding Her Voice In the Afterlife in ‘Ghosts’

Rebecca Wisocky On Hetty Finding Her Voice In the Afterlife in 'Ghosts'

New Oscar Site for Women and Nonbinary Writers Launches

New Oscar Site for Women and Nonbinary Writers Launches

March 24, 2023
2023 Emmy Predictions: Have Our Drama and Comedy Series Emmy Winners Marched In?

2023 Emmy Predictions: Have Our Drama and Comedy Series Emmy Winners Marched In?

March 24, 2023
The Best of SXSW 2023: ‘Air,’ ‘John Wick,’’Dungeons & Dragons’ and More Epic Crowd-Pleasers

The Best of SXSW 2023: ‘Air,’ ‘John Wick,’’Dungeons & Dragons’ and More Epic Crowd-Pleasers

March 24, 2023
2023 Emmy Predictions: Have Our Drama and Comedy Series Emmy Winners Marched In?

2023 Emmy Predictions: Have Our Drama and Comedy Series Emmy Winners Marched In?

by Clarence Moye
March 24, 2023
2

It's time to start taking the Emmy race seriously. Especially since the month of March debuted two extraordinarily strong contenders...

The Best of SXSW 2023: ‘Air,’ ‘John Wick,’’Dungeons & Dragons’ and More Epic Crowd-Pleasers

The Best of SXSW 2023: ‘Air,’ ‘John Wick,’’Dungeons & Dragons’ and More Epic Crowd-Pleasers

by Shadan Larki
March 24, 2023
6

I’m a few days removed from SXSW 2023; I’ve given myself time to sit with the 30+ movies and TV...

Apple Joins Amazon in Committing to Help Save Theaters

Apple Joins Amazon in Committing to Help Save Theaters

by Sasha Stone
March 23, 2023
55

The debate rages on as to whether films in theaters will survive. We already know event films will have no...

Doezzz ‘Yellowjackets’ Zzzeason 2 Avoid the Dreaded Zzzophomore Zzzlump?

Doezzz ‘Yellowjackets’ Zzzeason 2 Avoid the Dreaded Zzzophomore Zzzlump?

by Clarence Moye
March 21, 2023
0

We're back after a week off following the Academy Awards, and we're diving into one of our most feverishly anticipated...

daisy jones & the six music supervisor frankie pine

Music Supervisor Frankie Pine On Turning the Cast of ‘Daisy Jones & The Six’ Into Rock Stars

by Megan McLachlan
March 17, 2023
2

Daisy Jones & The Six music supervisor Frankie Pine talks to Awards Daily about band camp, featuring "Gold Dust Woman"...

Miami Film Festival

Rodrigo Sorogoyen’s ‘The Beasts’ Wins Three Awards at 40th Miami Film Festival

by Megan McLachlan
March 16, 2023
3

Miami, FL (March 16, 2023) – Goya Award-winner and Academy Award-nominated filmmaker Rodrigo Sorogoyen won several awards for his latest...

AwardsDaily Crew

  • About Us
  • Sasha Stone
  • Editor Ryan Adams
  • Editor Clarence Moye
  • Editor Mark Johnson
  • Contact Us

ADTV Crew

  • ADTV Home
  • Megan McLachlan, Editor
  • Joey Moser, Editor
  • Clarence Moye, Editor
  • Jalal Haddad, Senior Contributor
  • Shadan Larki
  • Ben Morris
  • David Phillips
  • Advertising on Awards Daily
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Oscar Podcast
  • AwardsDailyTV

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Good As Gold
  • AD TV
  • Calendar 2023
  • Podcasts
  • Interviews
  • Follow us on Twitter
    • Awards Daily
    • Sasha Stone
    • Ryan Adams
    • Clarence Moye
    • Mark Johnson
  • All News

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In