• About AwardsDaily
  • Sasha Stone
  • Advertising on Awards Daily
Awards Daily
  • 2026 Oscar Predictions
  • EmmyWatch
  • Buzzmeter
  • NextGen Oscarwatcher
No Result
View All Result
  • 2026 Oscar Predictions
  • EmmyWatch
  • Buzzmeter
  • NextGen Oscarwatcher
No Result
View All Result
Awards Daily
No Result
View All Result

Statsgasm Episode 4: Best Picture Nomination Voting Simulation (Pt. 1)

Marshall Flores by Marshall Flores
December 31, 2013
in Statsgasm
0

by Marshall Flores

Hello friends, and welcome back for another edition of Awards Daily’s Statsgasm! On this final day of 2013, we’re going to be taking a one-episode detour away from the art and science of AD’s prediction models. Instead, our focus today will be on the instant-runoff voting (IRV, also known as ranked choice voting) system AMPAS uses when determining Oscar nominations. In the effort to better understand the mechanics of this long-winded, complicated process, we will be running our own simulation of the Best Picture nominating process. This will also allow us to test a hypothesis that has been floating around the blogosphere recently – that a stronger film year with more potential BP contenders will result in fewer BP nominees.

As we all know, the Academy moved to a preferential ballot beginning in 2009 with regards to Best Picture voting, where voters would now rank multiple films on their lists. These ballots would then be tabulated under the IRV framework. AMPAS also initially doubled the Best Picture field from 5 to 10 nominees for a couple of years, before settling on a rule that requires every BP nominee to have #1 support from at least 5% of voters. Consequently, the number of BP nominees can now also vary from 5 to 10 films.

Now, I’ve read a number of articles attempting to explain AMPAS’s version of IRV, but frankly I think the nuances are lost on a general audience when IRV is discussed abstractly. As with regression analysis and the other statistical concepts I’ve introduced during Statsgasms’s run, I feel the best way to explain the BP nominating process is to actually see it in action. Longtime ADer (and fellow numbers nerd) Rob Y has been running voting simulations for the past few years using input directly from ADers, and they’ve been an excellent demonstration of the IRV system. I hope that our simulation over the next two days will be as effective and clear of a primer.

In order to simulate the BP nomination process, we will be using end-of-the-year top 10 lists from critics and bloggers that I’ve been compiling for the past few weeks as proxy ballots. I have collected and parsed 505 of these lists in total. Admittedly, it’s been an exhausting and tedious process that has certainly tested my resistance to carpal tunnel and being cross-eyed, but it has also been an enlightening one. 🙂 And yes, I know that critics and bloggers aren’t representative of AMPAS voters in many respects. Again, this is just a exercise to gives us an idea of the nuts and bolts in formulating a BP lineup.

But before we jump into the simulation, let’s see how the critics and bloggers are ranking 2013’s films on their top 10s. The following is a table displaying the overall top 20 films of these lists, ranked using a weighted score (where a #1 placement = 10 points, #2 = 9 points, #3 = 8, etc.)

criticstop20

Prospective BP frontrunners 12 Years a Slave, Gravity, and American Hustle are all ranked in the top 10, and as we can see, 12 Years and Slave and Gravity are *way* ahead of the others when it comes to #1 votes. Other contenders such as Inside Llewyn Davis, Her, and Nebraska are represented here as well. But the one thing to always remember is preferential balloting primarily rewards passion, i.e. #1 placements. We’ll soon see how much of this top 20 ends up making the BP lineup when our simulation is finished.

====

[NOTE: Since today, tonight and tomorrow are a holiday worldwide, we’ve decided to split this week’s episode of Statsgasm into two parts. We’ll ring out the old by looking back at Marshall’s summary of the Academy’s preferential balloting process. Then we’ll ring in the new tomorrow, looking forward past herculean task Marshall has undertaken to compile 505 separate Top 10 Lists to tabulate those ‘ballots’ and deliver the results in the Mother of All Top 20 Charts we see above. A few hours from now Part 2 will thrust us straight into the simulated belly of the balloting beast. – Ryan]

Tags: statsgasm
Previous Post

Best of 2013 – Roads, Doubles, Myths and Monsters

Next Post

Wolf and the Accusations of Presumed Misogyny

Next Post

Wolf and the Accusations of Presumed Misogyny

2026 Oscar Predictions: Can Hollywood Ever Recover From Life Inside the Doomsday Bunker?
2026 Oscar Predictions

2026 Oscar Predictions: Can Hollywood Ever Recover From Life Inside the Doomsday Bunker?

by Sasha Stone
June 13, 2025
0

Hollywood is teetering on the edge of collapse, or so industry insiders warn, despite a summer box office buoyed by...

Brian Wilson Passes On…

Brian Wilson Passes On…

June 11, 2025
Severence and The Studio Win Astras

Severence and The Studio Win Astras

June 11, 2025
Ari Aster’s Eddington Gets a Trailer

Ari Aster’s Eddington Gets a Trailer

June 10, 2025
Nextgen Oscarwatcher: The Life of Chuck thoughts

Nextgen Oscarwatcher: The Life of Chuck thoughts

June 9, 2025
Best Picture Watch: Teaser for Apple TV’s The Lost Bus

Best Picture Watch: Teaser for Apple TV’s The Lost Bus

June 8, 2025
2026 Oscar Predictions: Best Actress Will be a Barn Burner

2026 Oscar Predictions: Best Actress Will be a Barn Burner

June 6, 2025
George Clooney’s Good Night, Good Luck to Air on CNN – Right Message, Wrong Time

George Clooney’s Good Night, Good Luck to Air on CNN – Right Message, Wrong Time

June 6, 2025
Teaser Drops for Kiss of the Spider Woman

Teaser Drops for Kiss of the Spider Woman

June 7, 2025
Best Picture Watch: Wicked For Good Trailer Drops

Best Picture Watch: Wicked For Good Trailer Drops

June 5, 2025

Oscar News

2026 Oscars: Neon Nails it Again with Sentimental Value at Cannes

2026 Oscars: Neon Nails it Again with Sentimental Value at Cannes

May 22, 2025

2026 Oscars: New Rules Set for 9th Academy Awards

2026 Oscar Predictions: How the Oscar Game Destroys Movies

Best Picture Watch: Paul Thomas Anderson’s One Battle After Another Teaser

EmmyWatch

The Gotham TV Winners Set the Consensus to Come

The Gotham TV Winners Set the Consensus to Come

June 3, 2025

Gothams Announces Television Nominees

White Lotus Finale – A Deeply Profound Message for a Weary World

EmmyWatch: Apple-TV’s The Studio Could Have Been Great, But They Played it Safe

  • About AwardsDaily
  • Sasha Stone
  • Advertising on Awards Daily

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • About AwardsDaily
  • Sasha Stone
  • Advertising on Awards Daily

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.